Money making in Melvor Idle 2 — what actually pays
Thieving first, then mining and smithing, then fishing. After that, farm monsters by expected gold per kill.
Three things decide your gold per hour: what a kill is worth, how fast you kill it, and whether you survive long enough to keep going.
Early game order
Community guides agree on the shape of the first day: thieving needs no input materials and pays immediately; mining + smithing is the strongest first-day loop once you can smelt and sell gear; fishing takes over as the long-term money skill.
Why drop value beats raw gathering
Gathering sells one item at a fixed price. Combat sells a table: a monster's expected value is the sum of chance × quantity × sell price across its drops. A single rare drop can be worth more than an hour of logs.
Live: best farms by gold per kill
The mistake everyone makes
Comparing gold per kill without comparing kill speed. A 400 GP monster that takes 30 seconds loses to a 100 GP monster that takes 3 seconds. The Farm advisor multiplies by kills per hour for exactly this reason.
Sources: launch-week guides, community money-making breakdowns and the Melvor Idle 2 wiki, all checked 19 Nov 2026. The game is in Early Access; numbers move.